top of page

Review: A History We Can’t Escape: 'America USA' and the Dark History of Nation’s Anniversaries

15 minutes ago
7 min read

Those of us whose minds can immediately extract chapter and verse from any great poem as a way to connect with real life will sometimes be overwhelmed by what randomly comes across the transom. For example, consider the notion of time passages. Eddie S. Claude Jr’s America USA: How Race Shadows The Nation’s Anniversaries looks at the collective trauma some of us have been experiencing as the nation celebrated our 250th anniversary this year. Time moves in infinite circles, eats itself, with no beginning or end. The mood created through Claude’s six definitive chapters makes the poetic among us go back to T.S. Eliot’s The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock. That poem’s title hero, speaking in the midst of WWI (1915), saw the passing of his days with obvious fear and dread:


“I have measured out my life with coffee spoons;

I know the voices with a dying fall.”

…And when I am formulated…how should I begin/

To spit out all the butt-ends of my days and ways?”


Claude connects the coffee metaphor (surely inadvertently) with the title of his Introduction (“Bitterness at the bottom of the cup”) and his evocation of W.E.B. DuBois’ “Double Consciousness.” This was the notion, effectively developed through the course of the book, that “...the problem of the 21st century is the problem of America’s desperate avoidance of self-awareness.” Claude draws generously from the richest reservoir of Black excellence to make his points: DuBois, James Baldwin, and Frederick Douglass. The chapter on our centennial looks at the consequences of our “double consciousness” as post-Civil War reconstruction started to crumble. In 1926 we reckoned with European immigration and the mainstream dominant resurgence of the Ku Klux Klan, culminating in the Great Depression (that unifying economic malaise.) Finally, Stanley Foreman’s 1976 photograph, The Soling Of Old Glory, perfectly embodied our eternal division. A white teenager attacks a Black man on the steps of Boston City Hall in the midst of the city’s fiery busing protests.


Claude is very clear with his perspective here. This is not agitprop rage but rather a text that clearly understands how “...history and memory are repositories of funded experience.” His mission is to ensure that we move forward, even after what might for many seem to be the absolute hopelessness of a second Donald Trump administration (by the time you read this, by the way, the midterms will be over....). It might not seem we have been here before, especially in any of our lifetimes, but we will persevere. Norman Mailer (as quoted by Claude) insisted that history is interior. Perhaps that means it’s our job to reveal elements of it to each other. We live with our contradictions. “No matter what is said about us as the fever dream strikes again,” Claude writes, “we are not interlopers who need to prove ourselves repeatedly. Our loves close to the ground and in the ground make this place something worth fighting for.”


The primary mission of a text like America USA is to reveal truths that are reminders to some of us and revelations to others. In Chapter One, “Freedom is the White Man’s Gift,” he reminds us that Philadelphia was the birthplace of both the Constitution and the Fugitive Slave Act. In “What is the Fourth of July to us?” Claude reflects of Frederick Douglass’s 1852 speech in which he -- a freed black man who’d successfully escaped to the North in 1838 (at the age of twenty) -- reflected on the meaning of the holiday:


“...your celebration is a sham; your boasted liberty…your national greatness…your sounds of rejoicing are empty and heartless…”


Earlier in the speech, Douglass is no less conclusive in his need to set the record straight:


“America is false to the past, false to the present, and solemnly binds herself to be false to the future.”


Claude properly places Douglass in high esteem here. The speech stings perhaps even more in 2026 than it did in 1852. It’s in his reporting of Walt Whitman’s 1874 reflections on the possibility of black citizenship that the legendary poet of sensual abandon and freedom comes off, in my view, as a 21st century MAGA acolyte:


“As if we had not strained the voting…for the last fifty years with the millions of ignorant foreigners, we have now infused a powerful percentage of blacks, with about as much intellect and caliber (in the mass) as so many baboons.”


By the time we reach our centennial, Claude notes that many of Frederick Douglass’s Abolitionist friends (like Wllliam Loyd Garrison, Harriet Beecher Stowe, and Susan B. Anthony) were asking: “What else might the Negro want?” The notion of Emancipation and the never fulfilled promise of Forty Acres and a Mule for all formerly enslaved people was enough. The right to vote would have to wait. For Douglass, “Peace among the whites meant horrors for us.”


Things weren’t much better at our Sesquicentennial (1926). Pres. Woodrow Wilson, who had initially refused to come to Gettysburg and had written in 1901 that Black people were “excited about a freedom they did not understand,” used his time to argue that the 50 years since the horrors of that battle “... meant peace and union and vigor…. How wholesome and healing the peace has been!” The philosophy of “America First” seemed to have its greatest initial reception during this time, with the Ku Klux Klan taking credit for the reelection of Calvin Coolidge and the Johnson-Reed Immigration Act, excluding all Africans from this country and Japanese, Chinese, and Hindu immigrants.


The parallels between Calvin Coolidge of 1924 and our current Chief Executive 100 years later are alarming in their similarities. For Coolidge, slavery was irrelevant and the 1921 racial massacre in Tulsa apparently inconsequential. His goal was to sanctify American history, Philadelphia was a “holy shrine.” Independence Hall was “hallowed ground.” There was no need for a second revolution, an adjustment in who we had become at that point. With the fiery and virulent anti-antisemitism and general racism of Father Charles Coughlin never having died and in fact finding a greater acceptance now, Claude reflects that immigration had in fact expanded to include “European ethnics, and the Klan ‘shifted towards a simpler, purer racial system, with two categories: white and not white.”


“The American Century,” an interlude featured before Chapter Five, opens with a narrative about the Feb. 20, 1939 Madison Square Garden rally (with a crowd of 20,000 people) that seemed to be a poorly veiled tribute to Adolph Hitler. This was still in the time of “America First” and isolationists, of Charles Lindbergh and Father Coughlin’s insistence that “the spirit which opened the West and built our country is the spirit of the militant white man.” Claude carefully and effectively brings us through Emmett Till and Brown V Board of Education, the Little Rock battles in 1957 and our still painful reckoning with civil rights and the impending centennial of the US Civil War. Writer Robert Penn Warren argued that we were in fact not transformed by the sacrificial blood of the war. By 1961, on the eve of the Emancipation Proclamation’s centennial, Dr. Martin Luther King asked President Kennedy for a new proclamation. Instead, as a way to avoid offending potential Southern voters, he offered them “...a nice dinner party for the ‘who’s who’ in Black America…King asked for a new Emancipation Proclamation and he got a dinner.”


By 1976, Claude makes clear that the problems of our country, the dual consciousness, the refusal to fully confront the hypocrisy at the root of our founding, was not getting any easier:

“The appeal to consensus had lost its power by 1976, and the divisions were not mere abstractions; rather, they reflected the lived experiences of many on the margins of American society and revealed the contradictions at the heart of the Republic.”


By the 1980s and the ascendance of Ronald Reagan, Black History Week had been Black History Month since 1976. Move forward to as recently as 2021, when President Biden becomes the first President to attend a Tulsa, Oklahoma anniversary remembrance. Of particular interest here is clear and very direct words Biden spoke about our national reaction in the immediate aftermath of the event:


As soon as it happened there was a clear effort to erase it from our…collective memories…We do ourselves no favors by pretending none of this ever happened or that it doesn’t impact us today…


We do not know how our nation will assess itself on the occasion of our 250th birthday on July 4th., 2026. Claude sets the stage by reminding us what’s been on President Trump’s agenda since the earliest days of his second term. An Executive Order entitled “Restoring Truth and Sanity to American History” had as its stated goal to prevent the rewriting of our nation’s history, “...replacing objective facts with a distorted narrative driven by ideology rather than truth.” The Smithsonian Institution was “...accused of coming under the influence of a divisive, ‘race-centered ideology.” Claude calls for a Third Founding by the end of this book, a “revolution of values,” and he closes with an assurance that he (and the nation) will move forward:


...I will commemorate the fact that …America…still refuses to make real the promise of its own Declaration. Those principles are not lost because of the moral failings of men…And I claim these principles as my own!


There’s nothing smooth or logical about our history, and few texts will effectively argue otherwise. For every narrative that argues we were divinely inspired and driven by manifest destiny to assume this land is our land (and not necessarily yours), there are counter-narratives, stories that are closer to fact than anything now being posted on Truth Social. We will keep dealing with our past, keep trying to reconcile transgressions and injustices by at least earnestly working to set the record straight. Civil Rights Activist Bayard Rustin is generally credited with originating the “speak truth to power” quote that’s driven so many activists since its origin in 1942 and later publication in a 1955 American Friends Service Committee pamphlet. Eddie S. Glaude, Jr’s America USA: How Race Shadows The Nation’s Anniversaries is a powerful and effectively rendered argument for honesty, sanity, and a progressive future for our nation.

Comments


bottom of page